Mark Fennell All articles
Client Trust

The Status Question, Answered Early: A UK Consultant's IR35 Script

Mark Fennell
The Status Question, Answered Early: A UK Consultant's IR35 Script

Photo: Simon Carey , CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The question rarely arrives in a formal email. It comes at the end of a discovery call, just as the buyer is closing their notebook: 'One thing before we go — how do you handle IR35?' The consultant who answers with a shrug, a joke, or a defensive lecture on tax law has just introduced a doubt where none existed.

For UK buyers, especially medium and large private-sector organisations and public bodies, off-payroll working rules are not an abstract tax topic. They carry procurement risk, administrative burden, and the possibility of an unwanted letter from HMRC. The buyer is not usually trying to trap the consultant. They are trying to establish whether the engagement will be straightforward or whether it will create a problem for someone in finance or HR.

That makes the status question a trust question in disguise. Handled well, it becomes evidence that you understand the buyer's world. Handled badly, it becomes the reason a promising piece of work stalls before the proposal stage.

Why the Question Sounds Like an Accusation

When a buyer asks about IR35, it can feel as though they are questioning your independence, your business model, or your honesty. In practice, they are often checking their own position. Since the off-payroll working reforms, many medium and large clients must make a status determination and issue a status determination statement before the engagement begins. Public-sector bodies have similar responsibilities. A buyer who asks early is often a buyer who is trying to keep the project clean.

The consultant's instinct is to say 'I'm outside IR35' as quickly as possible. That phrase is understandable, but it is not a complete answer. Status depends on the working relationship — control, substitution, financial risk, and how the work is directed — not on a label in a contract. A buyer who hears a confident label with no supporting facts may become more suspicious, not less.

What the Buyer Is Actually Testing

The buyer is usually testing three things. First, do you know the rules well enough to avoid creating a problem for them? Second, can you provide the facts they need to make or record a determination? Third, will you accept the determination they reach, or will you argue about it later?

They are not looking for a legal opinion. They are looking for a professional who can discuss the engagement without evasion. A short, clear answer that acknowledges the buyer's process will almost always land better than a long assertion of status.

A Script for the First Exchange

The following script is not a substitute for legal advice, and it should be adapted to the facts of each engagement. Its purpose is to show the shape of a good answer: plain, early, and willing to work with the buyer's process.

'Thanks for raising it. I contract through my own limited company. Whether the engagement sits inside or outside the off-payroll rules depends on the working relationship — control, substitution, financial risk, and how the work is directed — not simply on what we call the contract. I am not going to give you a legal opinion on the call, but I can give you a clear account of how I work and the facts you need. If your organisation is responsible for the determination, I will work with your status determination statement. If you are exempt as a small company, the status test sits with my company and I will keep the appropriate records. Either way, I would rather settle it before we start than have it surface at invoice stage.'

That answer does several things. It names the mechanism without pretending to be a tax adviser. It offers evidence rather than assertion. It respects the buyer's process. And it moves the conversation from suspicion to administration, which is where it belongs.

Evidence Without Overclaiming

A script is stronger when it is backed by a short working-practices note. This need not be a legal document. One page covering the main facts is usually enough: how you are engaged, who directs the day-to-day work, how substitution is handled, what equipment you provide, how financial risk sits with your company, whether you can refuse work, and whether you serve other clients.

The note should be factual, not argumentative. Avoid presenting it as a guarantee that the engagement is outside the rules. Avoid treating an online status tool as a definitive answer. The note is there to help the buyer record what they need and to show that you have nothing to hide. If the buyer's determination is 'inside', the conversation should turn to how the engagement will operate, not to whether you can talk them out of it.

When the Client Is Too Small for the Rules

Some UK clients are exempt from the off-payroll working rules because they qualify as small companies. That does not mean the status question disappears. It means the responsibility shifts. If a buyer tells you they are small, ask them to confirm that in writing and keep your own records. Do not use the exemption as a reason to avoid the question. A buyer who later discovers that the exemption was misunderstood will remember who reassured them.

The Red Flag Is Evasion, Not the Answer

A clear answer is not always an 'outside' answer. Some engagements are genuinely inside the rules, and a consultant who can say so calmly, explain how the engagement will operate, and show that they understand the consequences is more credible than one who insists on a status the facts do not support.

The red flag is evasion. It is the consultant who changes the subject, jokes about HMRC, or sends a contract with no explanation. Buyers talk to other buyers. A reputation for being difficult on status travels faster than a reputation for being expensive.

A Short Note After the Call

Within a day of the conversation, send a short note. Summarise what was discussed, attach the working-practices page, and confirm who will make the determination. If the buyer has issued a status determination statement, acknowledge it. If they have asked for more information, provide it promptly. Keep the tone administrative rather than defensive.

The status question is not the most enjoyable part of business development, but it is one of the clearest tests of professional maturity. The consultant who answers it early, plainly, and in writing is not just avoiding a red flag. They are showing the buyer how they will behave when the engagement gets complicated.

All Articles

Related Articles

Reading the Polite Pause: Five Phrases That Tell a UK Buyer Is Drifting

Reading the Polite Pause: Five Phrases That Tell a UK Buyer Is Drifting

The Closing Map: What a UK Client Should Hold When the Consultant Steps Away

The Closing Map: What a UK Client Should Hold When the Consultant Steps Away

Two Chairs, One Standard: Adding a Second Consultant Without Splitting the Client's Confidence

Two Chairs, One Standard: Adding a Second Consultant Without Splitting the Client's Confidence